City Walk Kit vs. Buying Collar and Leash Separately: A Practical Comparison

Quick Answer

For most urban dog owners, the City Walk Kit offers better value and convenience than buying a collar and leash separately. It bundles a 33-inch city-length leash, a matching collar, and a waste bag holder, so you have everything in one cohesive system. However, if you already own a collar you love or need a specific collar size not available in the kit, buying separately might be the smarter choice.

When you're gearing up for daily city walks, the choice between a complete kit and individual pieces isn't just about price—it's about convenience, fit, and how well the gear works together. The City Walk Kit promises a streamlined walking experience, but is it worth it compared to picking out a collar and leash on your own?

In this comparison, we'll break down the real trade-offs: what you get in the kit, what you might miss, and how to decide based on your dog's size, your walking habits, and your budget.

What's in the City Walk Kit?

The City Walk Kit is a 3-piece system designed to solve common urban walking frustrations—like leash wrapping around your wrist, pockets full of treats, and no bag when you need one. According to the catalog, the kit includes a 33-inch 'city length' leash, a matching collar, and a waste bag holder, all valued at $120. The kit is currently offered at $60, which is a significant saving compared to buying each piece separately.

The 33-inch leash length is intentionally designed for city walking—short enough to keep your dog close in crowded areas, but long enough for a bit of exploration. The kit also comes with a free braided, rolled collar, which is a $55 value on its own. This makes the kit particularly appealing if you're starting from scratch or upgrading your current setup.

• The kit includes a 33-inch city-length leash, a matching collar, and a waste bag holder.
• The free braided, rolled collar is designed for hypoallergenic breeds to help prevent matting.
• The kit is priced at $60, a 50% discount from the combined $120 value.

Buying Separately: Flexibility and Customization

Buying a collar and leash separately gives you the freedom to mix and match based on your dog's specific needs. For instance, the Rolled Collar is sold individually at $27.50 (down from $55), and it's designed for hypoallergenic breeds to help prevent matting and keep your pup's neck comfortable. If you already have a leash you like, adding a rolled collar can be a cost-effective upgrade.

However, buying separately often means paying more overall. A standalone leash from another brand might cost $20–$40, and a quality collar another $20–$50. When you add a waste bag holder, the total can easily exceed the kit's $60 price. Plus, you have to ensure the leash and collar match in style and function, which can be a hassle.

• Separate purchases allow you to choose a collar size that fits perfectly, even if it's not included in the kit.
• You can prioritize a specific collar material, like the rolled collar for sensitive or hypoallergenic dogs.
• But you lose the bundle discount and the convenience of a coordinated set.

Value and Convenience: The Kit Advantage

The City Walk Kit offers a clear value advantage. At $60, you get a $120 value, including the free rolled collar. This is a 50% saving, which is hard to ignore. The kit also ensures that all pieces are designed to work together—the leash length, collar fit, and waste bag holder are all part of a cohesive system, so you won't have to worry about compatibility.

For city dwellers who walk daily, the convenience of having everything in one kit can't be overstated. You grab the kit, and you're ready. No second-guessing whether the leash clip fits the collar ring, or whether the waste bag holder is the right size. It's a streamlined experience that matches the brand's promise of 'reinventing dog walking.'

• The kit's 50% savings is a strong incentive for budget-conscious buyers.
• A cohesive system means less guesswork and more time enjoying your walk.
• The free rolled collar adds value, especially for dogs prone to matting.

Trade-Offs to Consider

• Cost: The City Walk Kit costs $60, which is half the $120 value. Buying a similar collar and leash separately could easily exceed $60, especially if you choose premium materials. If budget is a priority, the kit offers undeniable savings.
• Customization: Buying separately lets you pick a collar size that fits perfectly, even if it's not in the kit. The Rolled Collar, for example, is available in multiple sizes, so you can match your dog's neck exactly. If your dog has an unusual neck size, separate purchases may be necessary.
• Convenience: The kit comes as a complete system with a leash, collar, and waste bag holder. You don't have to worry about compatibility or style matching. For hassle-free city walks, the kit is the most convenient option.

Product Facts at a Glance

• City Walk Kit & FREE COLLAR: Meet The City Walk Kit 3-piece system ($120 value). PLUS our braided, rolled collar for FREE with purchase ($55 value). We’ve reinvented dog walking, we're tired of wrapping a leash around our wrist, filling our pockets with treats and not having a bag when our pup does the deed. All three pieces of this kit are top quality, and serve a unique purpose. City Length Leash: The 33-inch 'city length' leash is intentionally... This kit is designed to solve common urban walking frustrations, and the free rolled collar adds extra value, especially for dogs with sensitive coats.
• Rolled Collar: We were tired of ugly collars, and cheap quality. How long does it take to design & manufacture the world's first braided & rolled collar? It took us over a year to perfect. Our five star reviews will tell you the same. We designed this for hypoallergenic breeds, to help prevent matting, keep your pup's neck comfortable and their coat soft. What we didn't realize was how stunning it would also look on short... If you're buying separately, this collar is a great choice for dogs with long or hypoallergenic coats, as it helps reduce matting and keeps the neck comfortable.

Which Should You Choose?

Best for

• Urban dog owners who want a complete, coordinated walking system without the hassle of mixing and matching.
• Budget-conscious buyers who want maximum value—getting a $120 kit for $60, including a free rolled collar.

Not for

• Dog owners who already have a leash they love and only need a collar—buying the Rolled Collar separately is more economical.
• Owners of dogs with very specific neck sizes that might not be covered by the kit's collar options.

The City Walk Kit is a smart investment for most city dog owners, offering a complete, value-packed solution. But if you already have a leash or need a specific collar fit, buying separately—like the Rolled Collar—might be the better route. Weigh the trade-offs and choose what fits your dog's needs and your walking routine best.